Facebook Pixel


Who’s at fault- auto theft and accident

start your free consultation
Home Who’s at fault- auto theft and accident

What if I left my keys In the car?

Leaving your keys in your car can lead to many consequences, and the legal implications of such an action can vary depending on the circumstances. In most cases, if your car is stolen after you’ve left the keys inside, you are not automatically held responsible for any damage or accidents that may occur due to the theft. However, there are exceptions and unusual scenarios where liability may be imposed.

  1. General Rule of Non-Liability: Under the general rule of non-liability, when your car is stolen and the thief gets involved in an accident, you are typically not held responsible for the damages or injuries resulting from the accident. This is based on the principle that you cannot control the actions of a criminal who stole your vehicle.

  2. Unusual Facts and Exceptions: While the general rule absolves you of liability, there have been instances where the courts have deviated from this norm due to unusual circumstances. These exceptional cases are based on specific facts that distinguish them from typical car theft situations:

    • Car Dealership: In some cases involving car dealerships, where it was customary to leave keys in the cars on the lot, liability may be imposed if the dealership’s practices contributed to the theft and subsequent accident.

    • Bulldozer Keys: Leaving keys in a bulldozer may lead to an exception because it is highly unusual for a thief to have the knowledge and skill to operate such heavy machinery safely. In this case, a court may find that the owner’s negligence played a role in the theft.

    • Abandoned Vehicle: If a half-loaded truck is left parked for an extended period in a high-crime neighborhood, and someone seizes the opportunity to steal it, the court may consider the circumstances and assess liability differently. Negligence in securing the vehicle could come into question.

  3. Importance of Circumstances: The critical factor in these exceptional cases is the theft’s unique circumstances. Courts will consider whether the owner’s actions or omissions contributed to the theft, making them partially responsible for the subsequent consequences. The more negligent or reckless the owner’s behavior, the greater the likelihood of liability.

  4. Preventative Measures: To avoid potential legal complications and ensure your safety and the security of your vehicle, it’s essential to take preventative measures:

    • Always remove your keys from the vehicle when you are not driving.
    • Lock your car when it is unattended, even if you are just running a quick errand.
    • Park in well-lit and secure areas.
    • Do not leave valuables in plain sight inside your car, which can attract thieves.

If you leave your keys in your car, and it gets stolen, the general rule is that you are not held liable for any accidents or damages caused by the thief. However, unusual circumstances can lead to exceptions, and in some cases, the courts may impose liability based on specific facts and the owner’s negligence. To protect yourself and your vehicle, it’s best to practice responsible car ownership by taking preventive measures to minimize the risk of theft and associated legal complications.