Facebook Pixel


Who is at fault when a pedestrian is hit by a car?

start your free consultation
Home Who is at fault when a pedestrian is hit by a car?

Who is at fault when a pedestrian is hit by a car?

In pedestrian-car collisions, traffic laws play a significant role in establishing fault. In most jurisdictions, pedestrians have the right of way when using crosswalks, sidewalks, and designated pedestrian zones. Drivers are legally obligated to yield to pedestrians in these areas. Therefore, if a driver fails to yield to a pedestrian within these legally defined spaces, they are typically considered at fault for the collision.

Driver Negligence

Driver negligence is a common factor in pedestrian-car collisions. This can encompass various actions or failures to act, such as:

  1. Distracted Driving: If a driver was using their phone, adjusting the radio, eating, or engaging in any activity that diverts their attention from the road when the collision occurred, they may be liable.

  2. Speeding: Excessive speed reduces a driver’s reaction time and increases the severity of collisions. If drivers were speeding when they struck a pedestrian, they may be considered at fault.

  3. Failure to Obey Traffic Signals: Running red lights or ignoring stop signs can lead to collisions with pedestrians lawfully using crosswalks.

  4. Impaired Driving: Alcohol or drug impairment significantly impairs a driver’s judgment and reaction times. A driver under the influence who hits a pedestrian is typically held responsible.

  5. Failure to Yield: As mentioned earlier, drivers must yield to pedestrians in designated crosswalks. If a driver fails to do so, they may be found at fault.

Pedestrian Negligence

Pedestrians are also subject to rules and regulations to ensure their safety and the safety of others. Contributory negligence may be a factor if the pedestrian’s actions played a role in the collision. Examples of pedestrian negligence include:

  1. Jaywalking: Walking across the road outside of specified crosswalks or in disregard of traffic signals can increase the likelihood of accidents.

  2. Being Distracted While Walking: Pedestrians who divert their attention to phones or other devices while crossing the street may overlook approaching traffic.

  3. Ignoring Walk Signals: Pedestrians who enter the roadway against traffic signals indicating “Don’t Walk” may share some responsibility for accidents.

Comparative Fault

Many jurisdictions apply the concept of comparative fault when determining liability in pedestrian-car collisions. Comparative fault allows for assigning fault to both parties involved based on their contributions to the accident. For instance, if a pedestrian was jaywalking, but a speeding driver failed to react in time, the pedestrian and the driver may share responsibility for the collision.

Duty of Care

In legal terms, the duty of care refers to the obligation individuals have to act responsibly and avoid causing harm to others. Both drivers and pedestrians have a duty of care in traffic situations. When assessing fault, the court considers whether each party fulfilled their duty of care. If one party’s failure to uphold their duty of care led to the collision, they may be held responsible.

Witness Statements and Evidence

Eyewitness accounts and physical evidence are crucial in determining fault in pedestrian-car collisions. Statements from individuals who observed the accident can provide valuable insight into how the collision occurred. Additionally, evidence such as traffic camera footage, skid marks, and damage to the involved vehicles can help establish fault.

Intersection and Crosswalk Safety

Intersections and crosswalks are common locations for pedestrian-car accidents. While pedestrians typically have the right of way in crosswalks, drivers and pedestrians must exercise caution. Ensuring that crosswalks are clearly marked and well-lit can contribute to pedestrian safety. Likewise, drivers must be attentive and adhere to traffic laws, especially at intersections.

Seeking Legal Counsel

Determining fault in pedestrian-car collisions can involve various factors, laws, and regulations. If you or a loved one has been involved in such an accident, it’s advisable to seek legal counsel. An experienced personal injury attorney can assess the case details, gather evidence, interview witnesses, and navigate the legal complexities to help you seek appropriate compensation for your injuries and damages.

Establishing Fault for Pedestrian-Car Collisions

Determining fault in pedestrian-car collisions hinges on many factors, including traffic laws, driver and pedestrian negligence, comparative fault, and the duty of care. Seeking legal guidance and representation is crucial when navigating the aftermath of such accidents. By understanding the nuances involved in fault determination, individuals can better protect their rights and seek fair compensation in the event of a pedestrian-car collision.